November 19, 2026
Take a three-bedroom house bought in El Paso in 2021 for about $200,000, which was the metro's median that year. The couple put a little down and locked a 30-year rate near 3%. Early in 2021, Freddie Mac's weekly survey had the national average as low as 2.65%. Five years later the house is probably worth something close to the metro's September 2026 median of $283,950, and the couple is deciding whether one of them keeps it.
Most people start with the equity. They figure out how much the house gained, take half, and ask whether the spouse who stays can come up with that number. That's a fair place to start, but it leaves out the 3% mortgage, which is also worth something. In the usual setup, where a refinance funds the buyout, the spouse who keeps the house also gives up the old loan. At late-2026 rates, losing that loan raises the monthly payment by about as much as paying out the other spouse's share.
The example below uses round numbers so you can follow the math, not anyone's real file. It assumes a $190,000 loan at 3.0% taken out in 2021 and about five years of payments. It then compares a refinance at 7.11%, which was Freddie Mac's 30-year fixed average for the week of Nov. 12, 2026.
| Step | Loan amount | Rate | Monthly principal and interest |
|---|---|---|---|
| Original 2021 loan | $190,000 | 3.0% | about $801 |
| Balance owed after five years | about $169,000 | 3.0% | about $801 |
| Refinance the balance only, no buyout | about $169,000 | 7.11% | about $1,137 |
| Refinance the balance plus a half-equity buyout | about $226,500 | 7.11% | about $1,524 |
Here is where the buyout figure comes from. A house worth about $284,000 with $169,000 owed has roughly $115,000 in equity. Half of that is about $57,500, before selling costs or any other adjustments the two of you and your attorneys work out.
Read the table one row at a time. If the spouse who stays refinanced only the existing balance and paid no buyout, the payment would still go from about $801 to about $1,137. That $336 a month is the price of the rate alone. Adding the $57,500 buyout to the new loan raises the payment by about another $387. So of the roughly $723 monthly increase, close to half comes from the rate before a single dollar goes to the other spouse.
That changes the conversation at the kitchen table. "Can I afford to pay you out?" is only part of what the staying spouse is asking. The other part is "Can I afford to give up this loan?", and right now that part costs about $4,000 a year on a house like this one.
The El Paso household in this example is common. The Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas found that only 41% of U.S. mortgages carried rates above 3.8% as of July 2025. That means most borrowers nationally held loans at or below that level. That is a national figure, but a couple who bought or refinanced here in 2020 or 2021 is very likely sitting on one of those loans.
The figures in the table cover principal and interest only. Property taxes and homeowners insurance come on top of them, and after the refinance one income pays all of it. For reference, the combined listed 2026 rates for the City of El Paso, El Paso County, El Paso ISD, University Medical Center and El Paso Community College come to about $2.67 per $100 of taxable value, according to the El Paso County tax office's taxing-entities table. Everything here is general information to help you plan a conversation. It is not legal, tax or financial advice, so have your attorney, lender and tax professional confirm the numbers for your situation.
The other half of the decision is what it costs to live somewhere else, and El Paso has a public benchmark for that. HUD's Fair Market Rents for the El Paso area for fiscal year 2027 are $969 for a one-bedroom, $1,146 for a two-bedroom and $1,559 for a three-bedroom. El Paso Matters reported a 2024 median gross apartment rent of $1,082 in El Paso County, utilities included.
Line those up with the table. The keeping spouse's new principal and interest of about $1,524 is within a few dollars of HUD's three-bedroom benchmark of $1,559, and that is before taxes and insurance. Under the 3% loan, the same house cost about half the three-bedroom benchmark each month. The old loan made keeping the house cheaper than renting a comparable one. After the refinance, principal and interest alone cost about what renting a comparable house would.
That doesn't mean keeping the house is the wrong choice. Children's routines, a commute to Fort Bliss, a garage full of tools, or a backyard someone spent years on can all be worth more than the gap. The point is that the gap is real and measurable, and it's better to weigh it before an agreement is drafted than after.
When the numbers point toward selling, the next question is whether the market will cooperate. Through September 2026, it was still on the seller's side. The Texas A&M Real Estate Research Center recorded 737 sales in the El Paso metro that month, a $283,950 median and 3.41 months of inventory. That level of supply is tight. We covered why El Paso stayed this way while much of Texas loosened in our look at the 2026 market.
Tight doesn't mean fast, though, and divorce timelines need to account for that. The center's September 2026 spotlight report put El Paso's average days to sell at 113, a number that counts both time on the market and the weeks to closing. Plan on roughly a season from listing to funding. A house priced off a headline number instead of its own street can take longer than that. In a divorce, every extra month means another mortgage payment split between two households.
Selling also turns the equity from the example into cash for both spouses, roughly $57,500 each before costs. Each of you can then decide on your own terms whether to buy again, rent or wait. Whoever buys next will do it at current rates too, so selling doesn't avoid the 7% loan. It means each of you takes on a new loan sized to what you choose to buy, not a larger loan built around a buyout.
What if rates drop before we decide?
At 6.5%, the $226,500 loan in the example would run about $1,432 a month in principal and interest, compared with about $1,524 at 7.11%. Paying about $92 a month less helps. It still leaves the payment far above the $801 the 3% loan cost, so a modest drop in rates doesn't change the overall picture.
Our house isn't a 2021 median-priced house. Does this still apply?
The amounts change, but the pattern holds for any couple holding a loan from the low-rate years. A higher price or a larger original loan makes the rate portion of the increase bigger in dollars. A home bought before 2020, when El Paso's annual median was $162,450 in 2019, usually has a smaller balance and more equity. In that case the buyout portion tends to be larger than the rate portion.
Who should run our real numbers?
A lender should price the refinance, and your attorney handles the agreement. We can tell you what the house is likely to sell for in today's market and how long a sale might take, which is the starting point for both of their calculations. For more on the selling side, see our guide to handling a home sale during a divorce in El Paso.
If you're deciding whether to keep the house or sell it, the buyout math starts with what the house is worth today. Derek & DJ work with divorcing homeowners through our Certified Divorce Real Estate service. Call or text us for a free 15-minute market evaluation, and we'll give you a value both of you can take to your lender and attorney.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.